-- Advertisement --

Anti-Corbyn Labour MP defends sacked ally who compared Jewish colleagues to Nazis

-- Advertisement --

Stay in touch!

Sign up to be updated with Evolve's latest stories, and for opportunities to get involved.

A Labour MP who has repeatedly attacked Jeremy Corbyn for ‘not doing enough about antisemitism’ has been roundly criticised after attempting to defend a right-wing Labour Peer who was sacked over comments described as “grossly insensitive to Jewish staff“, and which are said to ‘breach the IHRA definition of antisemitism’.

On Wednesday evening, Jeremy Corbyn took the decision to sack Labour Peer, Dianne Hayter, from the Shadow Cabinet after it emerged that she had compared his leadership team, which includes a number of Jewish staff such as James Schneider and Carl Shoben, to Nazis.

Speaking during a meeting of the right-wing Labour First faction, Hayter attempted to compare the behaviour of Jeremy Corbyn’s inner circle with the last days of Hitler, stating:

“Those of you who haven’t [read the book] will have seen the film Bunker, about the last days of Hitler, where you stop receiving any information into the inner group which suggests that things are not going the way you want.”

“That seems to be where we are at the moment: having the leadership in a bunker so they are not hearing in those views, that evidence, that is in conflict with what they are trying to do, to the extent that even undermines what they are trying to do.”

Following the emergence of her comments, Hayter was immediately sacked from her position as a Shadow Brexit Minister, with a Labour spokesperson stating:

“Dianne Hayter has been sacked from the frontbench position with immediate effect for her deeply offensive remarks about Jeremy Corbyn and his office.”

“To compare the Labour leader and the Labour Party staff working to elect a Labour government to the Nazi regime is truly contemptible, and grossly insensitive to Jewish staff in particular.”

In September 2018, Labour adopted the IHRA definition of antisemitism in full into their rulebook, and Ms Hayter’s comments – which actively compare a number of Jewish staff to Nazis – have been widely described as being ‘in breach of the definition’.

Furthermore, Labour members using such ‘Hitler metaphors’ is specifically mentioned as highly insensitive in the Chakrabarti Report – Labour’s official inquiry into antisemitism.

Despite this, Labour MP Wes Streeting – who has repeatedly criticised Jeremy Corbyn for supposedly not doing enough to combat antisemitism in the party – attempted to defend Hayter, describing her sacking as “a gross over-reaction“:

Streeting has also previously stated his belief that there should be “no compromising on the IHRA definition and all of its examples“:

Responding to Streeting’s defence of Hayter, the Editor of Novara Media, Aaron Bastani, claimed that the Labour MP should also be suspended for defending Hayter’s ‘antisemitic comments’, stating:

“There are Jewish people among Corbyn’s staff, and inner circle. Hayter’s comments, according to the IHRA, are anti-Semitic.”

“Which means Hayter should be suspended. And if Streeting thinks her behaviour is acceptable so should he.”

Streeting’s attempt to defend the right-wing Labour Peer was also roundly criticised as hypocritical by numerous other social meda users:

Streeting is widely believed to be under threat of deselection by his local Ilford North CLP during this summer’s reselection process.

-- Advertisement --

Evolve needs your help more than ever!

We rely on the generosity of our readers to help fund the majority of our work - but we need a little more to make ends meet and enable us to grow.

If we can reach 1,000 regular subscribers, we will become entirely financially sustainable - and we'll also have a little extra so we can build upwards and outwards to make our work have an even bigger impact.

In the last month alone, our work on the Environment Bill has helped force a change in the law for the better. And, since Evolve was founded, our uniquely viral style of journalism has repeatedly put the establishment on the back foot and helped force genuinely positive progression.

But we want to do far more - and we need your help to do it.

The best way you can help us is by becoming a Monthly or Annual subscriber. This kind of regular income allows us to better plan for the future - firstly so we can pay the bills, and then so we can set aside funds and time to work on extra projects.

However, if you can't commit to a regular payment, one-off donations - no matter how small - also make a big difference to us, and we genuinely make the most of every single penny.

So, if you appreciate the work that Evolve does and you want to see us make an even bigger impact on the world, please think about contributing to our work in whatever way you possibly can.

Tom D. Rogers

Co-Founder, Contributing Editor

Jess Miller

Co-Founder, Contributing Editor

Subscriber-Only Comments