The Jewish Labour MP who faced disciplinary action by the party after reportedly screaming in Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn’s face and calling him a “f*cking antisemite” has faced a widespread backlash from all sides, including many in the Jewish community, after comparing her treatment by the Labour Party to Nazi Germany.
Despite the Labour Party dropping any disciplinary action against her more than a week ago, Dame Margaret Hodge reportedly told Sky News in an a interview this evening that she ‘felt the same fear her father would have felt when he was fleeing Nazi Germany when she found out Labour had opened disciplinary proceedings against her’.
Dame Margaret Hodge has told Sky News she felt the same fear her father would have felt when he was fleeing Nazi Germany when she found out Labour had opened disciplinary proceedings against her
— Sky News Breaking (@SkyNewsBreak) August 16, 2018
Hodges’ exact words were:
“On the day that I heard that they were going to discipline me, and possibly suspend me, it felt almost like – I kept thinking, ‘what did it feel like to be a Jew in German in the 30s’.
Because it felt almost as if they were coming for me. And it’s rather difficult to define, but there’s that fear, and it reminded me of what my dad used to say. He always said to me as a child ‘you’ve got to keep a packed suitcase at the door, Margaret – in case you ever have to leave in a hurry’.
And when I heard about the disciplinary, my emotional response resonated with that feeling of fear that was clearly at the heart of what my father felt when he came to Britain.”
Jewish Labour MP @margarethodge says the moment she found out she faced investigation for confronting @jeremycorbyn over anti-Semitism made her think about "what it felt like to be a Jew in Germany in the 30s"
— Sky News Politics (@SkyNewsPolitics) August 16, 2018
Hodge’s father, Hans Oppenheimer, fled Nazi Germany during the late 1930s, narrowly avoiding the start of the Holocaust in which six million Jews and hundreds of thousands of other minorities such as Romany Gypsies and LGBT people were murdered.
Unsurprisingly, Hodge’s astonishing comparison between Labour’s disciplinary process and her father fleeing the Holocaust came in for fierce criticism.
A Labour spokesman reportedly responded by saying the comparison was “extreme and disconnected from reality“.
Furthermore, Hodge’s comments even sparked a backlash from one prominent Jewish Corbyn-critic, David Baddiel.
The Jewish Comedian has made no secret of his criticism for Jeremy Corbyn’s handling of the Labour antisemitism row, but chose to slam Hodge’s stark comparison between Labour’s disciplinary proceedings and fleeing the Holocaust as “bollocks“:
Well. That I'm afraid – and I speak both as someone who is not a fan of the cult of Jeremy, and whose mother fled Nazi Germany – is bollocks. https://t.co/IdaMB5s5Oj
— David Baddiel (@Baddiel) August 16, 2018
My grandmother fled the Nazis in 1938 and got out by the skin of her teeth, her brother had an even closer escape, their father and half their extended family never made it.
This analogy is so utterly offensive it’s hard to express how disgusted I am https://t.co/ZC0BrdkJy2
— Rosa (@rosagilbert) August 16, 2018
In fact, Hodge’s comments came in for near universal condemnation on Twitter, with many pointing out that if the general public didn’t think the antisemitism row was being used for political gain before, Hodge’s extremely exaggerated hyperbole would understandably lead many to believe it was now:
Here we have Margaret Hodge comparing a Labour Party disciplinary hearing to being chased out of Nazi Germany by the Gestapo. What a ludicrously appalling and disingenuous statement to make. Have you absolutely no shame? https://t.co/byfZZH0Nsx
— Sam Swash (@sam_swash) August 16, 2018
The insensitivity and hysteria inherent in Hodge’s comparison was highlighted by another Twitter user, who posted a 2015 quote from Jewish journalist Anshel Pfeffer which perfectly highlighted the glaring difference:
“If they honestly think that the situation in Britain today echoes the 1930s when Jews were still banned from a wide variety of clubs and associations, when a popular fascist party, supported by members of the nobility and popular newspapers, were marching in support of Hitler, when large parts of the British establishment were appeasing Nazi Germany and the government was resolutely opposed to allowing Jewish refugees of Nazism in to Britain, finally relenting in 1938 to allow 10,000 children to arrive — but not their parents who were to die in the Holocaust (that shameful aspect of the Kindertransport that is seldom mentioned) — and when the situation of Jews in other European countries at the time was so much worse, then not only are they woefully ignorant of recent Jewish history but have little concept of what real anti-Semitism is beyond the type they see online.
[…] To compare today’s Britain, for all its faults, with the Jews’ situation in 1930s exhibits a disconnect from reality which borders on hysteria.”
Also during her interview with Sky News, Margaret Hodge stated that she believed there was a fine line between being pro-Palestinian and being antisemitic, stating:
“There’s a very fine line between being pro-Palestinian – the Palestinian cause, which [Corbyn has] always believed in – and being antisemitic. And I think he’s gone the wrong side of that line.”
Hodge’s comment that there was a fine line between the two also came in for criticism from many, including the prominent Jewish pro-Corbyn activist Michael Segalov:
this is complete nonsense from Margaret Hodge. it is not a 'fine line' between fighting anti-Semitism and supporting Palestinian people in their struggle. you can do both just fine. to suggest anything otherwise is dangerous and disingenuous. ugh. (fixed) pic.twitter.com/Dbq62hjV8h
— Michael Segalov (@MikeSegalov) August 16, 2018
'Fine line'? Sorry, this is an outrageous statement by Margaret Hodge. Outrageous on so many levels. Let's please tackle anti-Semitism on the left without throwing Palestinians, or their supporters on the left, under the bus please. FFS. https://t.co/R2si1Wdm1s
— Mehdi Hasan (@mehdirhasan) August 16, 2018
Being in favour of Palestinians having rights has nothing to do with being antisemitic. This is dangerous nonsense pic.twitter.com/UfR3fBFDxJ
— Matt Zarb-Cousin (@mattzarb) August 16, 2018
It remains to be seen whether or not those within the Labour Party who have previously supported Hodge will change their stance and call out what have been near universally-condemned quotes.
Become An Evolve Politics Subscriber
Your subscriptions go directly into paying our writers a standard fee for every article they produce. So if you want to help us stay truly independent, please think about subscribing. We literally couldn’t function without the support of our fantastic readers.Subscribe
Or a One-Off Donation to Evolve Politics
If you don’t want to subscribe, but still want to contribute to our project, you can make a one-off donation via the donate button below. All your donations go directly to our writers for their work in exposing injustice, inequality and unfairness.Donate