-- Advertisement --

Man declared ‘fit for work’ is found dead on beach after asking “What’s the point?”

-- Advertisement --

Stay in touch!

Sign up to be updated with Evolve's latest stories, and for opportunities to get involved.

A man declared ‘fit for work’ by the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP), despite suffering with extreme anxiety, stress and panic attacks for nine years, has been found dead on a beach after his sickness benefits were removed. 

Following the removal of his benefits, 54-year-old David Metcalf was visited by police and a mental health practitioner after concerns for his well being were raised.

Just four days later he was found dead on a Durham beach.

The coroner ruled that Mr Metcalf had died ‘as a result of immersion in water, but it was not clear whether he came to be in the sea deliberately or by accident’.

“He said he was frustrated and upset and thought ‘What’s the point?'”

In a heart wrenching report, the Hartlepool Mail said that Mr Metcalf was described as a ‘somewhat solitary individual’ who only had one acquaintance, a local garage owner. Mr Metcalf had given the garage owner his car keys and bank documents, saying he would no longer need them. Concerned for Mr Metcalf’s wellbeing, he alerted the police.

Mr Metcalf was then examined by mental health practitioner Leighann Fishpool, whose haunting report said: 

David was signed off sick for nine years due to anxiety, stress and panic attacks.


He has recently been deemed fit for work and told he would need to go to the JobCentre to claim Jobseeker’s Allowance.


He said he was frustrated and upset and thought ‘What’s the point?’


He feels he needs someone to go with him to the JobCentre so they can sort this out for him.


He feels frustrated at having his benefits stopped and finds it difficult to communicate with staff at the JobCentre.

However, Mr Metcalf denied that he had any intention of harming himself and ‘displayed no signs of major mental illness’.

“The suicide conclusion is not available”

Mr Metcalf was found still dressed in a jumper, coat and gloves, however he was not wearing any socks or underwear. Detective Sergeant Gary Davison described this as ‘not necessarily unusual for someone like Mr Metcalf’. 

The coroner, Mr Oliver, said: 

I simply cannot come to the conclusion beyond reasonable doubt that he intended to kill himself and, therefore, the suicide conclusion is not available.


Despite the best efforts of the police, there is no conclusive evidence as to how Mr Metcalf came to be in the sea.


Accordingly, and I say this with regret, but this is an inquest that must record an open conclusion and that is what it will do.

Robotic assessments

Between 2011 and 2014, DWP statistics revealed that 2,380 people died shortly after being declared for work. There is clearly an ongoing problem with the way DWP are assessing benefits claimants. There are even claims coming to light of assessors ‘lying’ in the reports that lead to people losing benefits. 

Mr Metcalf’s tragic story is both heart breaking and eye opening. Faced with robotic assessments and often shunned by society, vulnerable people are being pushed into isolation and not receiving the help they so desperately need and deserve.

If you or someone you know is showing signs of being unable to cope, do not be afraid to act:

  • The Samaritans can be contacted for free at any time by ringing 116 123 from any phone.
  • By volunteering with The Samaritans, you can help support people across the UK and Ireland when they are going through a difficult time in their life.
  • If you or someone you know are facing a PIP assessment, be prepared. The CAB offer invaluable advice.

Become An Evolve Politics Subscriber

Your subscriptions go directly into paying our writers a standard fee for every article they produce. So if you want to help us stay truly independent, please think about subscribing. We literally couldn’t function without the support of our fantastic readers.

Or a One-Off Donation to Evolve Politics

If you don’t want to subscribe, but still want to contribute to our project, you can make a one-off donation via the donate button below. All your donations go directly to our writers for their work in exposing injustice, inequality and unfairness.


-- Advertisement --

Evolve needs your help more than ever!

We rely on the generosity of our readers to help fund the majority of our work - but we need a little more to make ends meet and enable us to grow.

If we can reach 1,000 regular subscribers, we will become entirely financially sustainable - and we'll also have a little extra so we can build upwards and outwards to make our work have an even bigger impact.

In the last month alone, our work on the Environment Bill has helped force a change in the law for the better. And, since Evolve was founded, our uniquely viral style of journalism has repeatedly put the establishment on the back foot and helped force genuinely positive progression.

But we want to do far more - and we need your help to do it.

The best way you can help us is by becoming a Monthly or Annual subscriber. This kind of regular income allows us to better plan for the future - firstly so we can pay the bills, and then so we can set aside funds and time to work on extra projects.

However, if you can't commit to a regular payment, one-off donations - no matter how small - also make a big difference to us, and we genuinely make the most of every single penny.

So, if you appreciate the work that Evolve does and you want to see us make an even bigger impact on the world, please think about contributing to our work in whatever way you possibly can.

Tom D. Rogers

Co-Founder, Contributing Editor

Jess Miller

Co-Founder, Contributing Editor

Subscriber-Only Comments